Frame Comparison - Bar Curve X and Bar Top Y for Road Bikes

Frame Comparison - Bar Curve X and Bar Top Y for Road Bikes

In order to enhance the usefulness of our Frame Comparison tool we’ve added additional metrics that aid in precisely matching positions.
These metrics are Bar Curve X and Bar Top Y.
Bar Curve X and Bar Curve Y relative to bottom bracket
To calculate these metrics for road bikes we add the handlebar reach to the Handlebar X value. And the stack of the top of the handlebar to the Handlebar Y value.
Zooming in on the bars:
Bar Curve X and Bar Curve Y defined
It is important to note that the reach point on the bar curve is to the centre of the tube. And the stack point is to the highest point on the outer section of the bars near the hoods.
We’ve created these metrics for several reasons.
  1. To account for variations in bar design
  1. To make it easier for fitters to match positions

Variations in bar design

While there have long been variations on the classic Maes bar, we are starting to see a lot more variety in shapes, partially thanks to the rise in popularity of Gravel riding.
The Specialized Hover bar and BP4 bar are examples of opposite ends of the spectrum:
Specialized Hover BarSpecialized Hover Bar

BP4 BarBP4 Bar

The Specialized rises by 15mm while the BP4 drops by 54mm. This leads to a significant difference in the height of the hoods, for the same Bar XY. Or a significant difference in Bar XY if you wish to maintain the hood position.

Easier for fitters

We’ve linked the Frame Comparison tool to the tables of component information we keep in Fit Essentials. Making it extremely quick to compare different bar/stem combinations.
Frame Comparison screenshot showing selection of handlebarsFrame Comparison screenshot showing selection of handlebars
In the example above you can see that changing the bars for a rise option offers the possibility to reduce the spacer stack under the stem.
Frame Comparison screenshot with standard vs long-reach barFrame Comparison screenshot with standard vs long-reach bar

Why did we choose these points?

Bar XY is easy to understand because you measure from one point (centre of the BB) to another (centre of handlebar) in two dimensions. But there isn’t a reliable point to do this with on the bars.
Bar Top has the advantage of being easy to measure and not heavily affected by the inclination of the bars.
Bar Curve is also fairly easy to measure and can be calculated using information provided by most bar manufacturers.
The goal with these metrics is to define a useful approximation for the virtual intersection of the handlebar with the hoods. Going beyond the metrics we have defined would require knowing exact details of the handlebar bend and hood interface.
You can find frame comparison in the “Free tools” menu at the top of the page.
If you have any questions please use the chat button at the bottom right of this screen (please note that we are on New Zealand time)
See also:
  1. Our free Frame Comparison tool
  1. A guide to Using Frame Comparison
  1. Using Bar XY Cartesian Coordinates
  1. Our Advanced Bike Finder tool

    • Related Articles

    • Using frame comparison

      The free velogicfit Frame Comparison tool offers a quick, fully-user-controlled way of comparing two frames side by side. You’ll find frame geometry, images (if available) and frame specifications. If you’ve got a target Bar X & Y (e.g. from a ...
    • Using Bar XY Cartesian Coordinates

      Over the last few years it has become standard practice for bike manufacturers to provide Reach and Stack figures in their geometry charts. As shown below, these metrics give the coordinates of the top of the Head Tube relative to the Bottom Bracket. ...
    • Taking bike measurements

      On the capture screen you will see a button for “MEASURE BIKE”: Clicking “MEASURE BIKE” will open the bike measurement popup window: Bike measurement window Follow the instructions on screen to use the wand to acquire the indicated points. Once you ...
    • Road metrics

      Our system offers an extensive range of metrics. Using 3D data well requires combining multiple factors in your decision making. Here is some guidance for "orthodox" positions.  Metric Range Ankle Angle Average 100-130, range < 30 Knee Angle Max ...
    • Velogic Studio bike measurements defined

      Our Velogic Studio system collects a detailed set of bike measurements that combine both traditional relationships and modern XY metrics. Bike measurements as shown in Velogic Studio The definitions for these measurements are listed below. Saddle ...